Putin’s War and the
Murder of Boris Nemtsov
On the day after Nemtsov’s
murder, the photograph of him lying gunned down on the bridge ran on the front
page of the Wall Street Journal, right above a story explaining that the US is
limiting the spy-satellite intelligence it provides Ukraine to avoid provoking
Russia, and that the Obama administration also remains deeply divided over
granting lethal aid a year after it was requested by Kyiv.
The contrast between
the horror in Moscow and the dysfunction in Washington is revealing and also
very disconcerting. The image from the bridge radiates globally because Russia
under Putin is a danger not only to Ukraine but to Europe, the US, and the
entire international order. The refusal to provide meaningful aid to Ukraine, a
country that is fighting for its freedom and territorial integrity against this
danger, will only invite more Russian aggression, and it will not end with
Ukraine. This is a lesson that has had to be learned too many times in history,
and we need to learn it again—quickly—before much more harm is done.
Boris Nemtsov,
1959–2015
Whoever pulled the trigger—the collective trigger was pulled
by all those, from television propagandists to Vladimir Putin himself, who over
the last several years, and especially after the beginning of the war with
Ukraine, sponsored a campaign of hatred, intimidation, and aggression against
those they labeled “national traitors” and “the fifth column”—Russian democrats
and all those who opposed Putin and his policies. Just days ago, pro-Kremlin
organizations staged a hate-filled rally in downtown Moscow, openly calling for “cleansing” Russia from “the
fifth column.” The placards they carried had the picture of Boris
Nemtsov.
State television channels that
hounded and slandered Nemtsov until the very last day of his life—the latest
episode purporting to show his “links with the West” was scheduled to be
broadcast on NTV on March 1st—have immediately changed their tune, claiming
that the opposition leader was “insignificant” and “no threat” to Putin. “An
average citizen,” Putin’s official spokesman quipped.
Stalin’s Caucasus crimes Putin wants you to forget
Despite claims that USSR
embraced Internationalism, in reality nationality and ethnicity always
mattered. It didn’t matter that many Kalmyks, Tatars or Chechens had fought in
the Red Army too, in the words of Simon Sebag-Montefiore, Stalin “certainly
carried all the traditional Georgian prejudices against the Muslim peoples of
the Caucasus whom he was to deport.” And that’s not only true for the peoples
of the Caucasus. Throughout his reign as ruler of the USSR, Stalin absorbed
Russian nationalism and by doing so absorbed all the traditional hatreds and
prejudices against other peoples that went along with it.
The deportation of the Chechen
and Ingush peoples was part of Stalin’s great deportation plan of ethnic
minorities in the USSR:
·
900,000 Soviet Germans, 89,000 Finns deported in
1941 & 1942
·
69,267 Karachais deported to Central Asia 19 Nov
1943
·
91,919 Kalmyks deported to Siberia 28–29 Dec
1943
·
478,479 Chechen and Ingush peoples deported to
Siberia on 23 Feb 1944
·
37,107 Balkars deported to Kazakstan on 8–9 Mar
1944
·
180,014 Crimean Tatars deported to Uzbekistan on
18–20 Mar 1944
·
91,095 Meshketian Turks deported from Soviet
Georgia later in 1944
These crimes against
humanity form yet another stain against the former USSR and its predecessor,
the Tsarist Russian Empire, both of whom today’s Russian leader Vladimir Putin
expressly admires. Against this background, it is unsurprising, then, that Putin
has continued the legacy of repressive measures regarding any attempt at
commemorating these historic events.
The Absurd World of
Russian Public Opinion
http://www.themoscowtimes.com/opinion/article/the-absurd-world-of-russian-public-opinion/516531.html
The overwhelming majority of Russians believe that
the West attacked Russia in Ukraine and not that Russia seized
part of Ukraine's territory and is now actively helping separatists
in eastern Ukraine with regular army soldiers, volunteers and heavy
weapons.
They believe not that the Ukrainian people ousted former
President Viktor Yanukovych because of his unparalleled theft
and lies, but that the United States and CIA agents overthrew
him by using Maidan as a tool for replacing the pro-Russian
regime in Kiev with an anti-Russian "junta."
Most Russians believe that this country's economic problems
are not the fault of the Russian authorities, their corrupt
and monopolistic policies, their seizures of private property
and practice of corporate raids or their policy of high and ever-rising
costs for business, but stem from the machinations of the West,
which dreams only of how it can destroy Russia.
In one kindergarten
in the Moscow area, a teacher painted this picture of the world
for her five-year-old wards. "The Ukrainians wanted to live with
Russia, but the Americans wanted the Ukrainians to live with
them. The Americans bomb Ukrainian cities. But don't be afraid.
The Russian army is stronger than everyone and will save us
from the Americans. Our president is good. He stands for peace. He
sends weapons to the separatists and we will win soon. After that,
one little boy cried out, "Hurray! It's world war! We'll beat everybody!"
Russian soldier fighting in Ukraine is proud of Putin
for deceiving the world
A common misperception in the West is a somewhat naïve
expectation that Russian people would rebel, if they only knew that Putin is covertly sending soldiers to
fight and die in another sovereign country. The fact is, many of them already
know. Blinded by shameless Russian propaganda, they don’t mind the fact that
their government is obfuscating the facts and lying to the world. To the
contrary, they’re proud of their fibbing President. In their imagination,
inflamed by Russian mainstream media, the end justifies the means. They don’t
mind it when lies are spouted from the Kremlin, because many Russians see
themselves at war with the West. “The information war” is therefore part of
this one-sided grandstanding, where anything goes. Believing Putin’s lie about
“NATO legions” in Ukraine, many Russians are content to believe that their
military battalions are waging battle against these imaginary Western
opponents. What they fail to realize is that while Putin is lying to the world,
he is also lying to the Russians.
Russian mainstream media and the country’s leading
propagandists (designated as so-called “guardians” of the establishment) callously disseminate
images of dead and injured children in the Middle East, passing
them off as casualties of the Ukrainian military. They show off
images of Russia’s brutalities in Chechnya, representing them as
Ukraine’s alleged slaughter of its own civilians. They ludicrously exclaim that
Ukrainian armed forces are “crucifying children and forcing their mothers to
watch.” Quite simply, Russia lies to
everyone. These falsehoods affect the country’s citizens in the
most profound way: by convincing them to give up their very lives for the sake
of defeating their alleged arch-nemesis. Instead of the phantom “NATO legions,”
they savagely attack Ukrainian military and civilians on Ukrainian soil. As
Slavoj Žižek once said, “[T]he horror of Communism, Stalinism, is not that bad
people do bad things — they always do. It's that good people do horrible things,
thinking they are doing something great."
The story of a Russian soldier’s war in Ukraine: “We all knew what
we had to do and what could happen”
This is a
long interview with a badly injured Russian soldier, A Buryat from Ulaan Ude in
the Far East. He describes his
recruitment, training, the steps taken to hide the fact there are regular Russian
soldiers in Ukraine and the battle in which he was injured.
We found Radio Sputnik. And
there was a debate, if there were soldiers here in Ukraine. And all the guests
were like, “No-no-no!” And here’s our company, like, yeah, right. Well, who
would admit it openly? Our government does realize it has to help, but
officially sending the troops in would rile up Europe and NATO. However, you do
realize NATO is also in it, sure, they are sending them weapons.
Ukraine Live Day 378: Severely Injured Russian Soldier Describes
Deployment to Ukraine
This is a detailed military analysis of the above interview and the link is a good source of day to day
reporting on the war in Ukraine.
The soldier sustained severe burns after ammunition went off
inside his tank, causing a fire. He was evacuated in an APC and was taken
first to Gorlovka, and from there to Donetsk, where he is now in a burns unit
in the region's central hospital. He hopes to return to Russia soon.
Batomunkuev makes no secret of
his identity. He is a soldier in the 5th independent tank brigade (based in
Ulan-Ude). He was conscripted on November 25, 2013 and signed a three-year
military service contract (enabling him to be deployed outside his region) on
June 2014.
Before leaving for Rostov,
back in Ulan-Ude, the unit had painted over their tanks, covering numbers and
unit markings. All insignia patches were removed when they arrived at their
camp. Passports were left at their home base.
On leaving the camp, they
were told to hand over mobile phones and documentation. It appears the Russian
military is attempting to clamp down on potentially revealing photos and
reports appearing on social media, or for bodies to be found with identifiable
documents.
It's not much of a shock that the typical Russian citizen wouldn't blame the government or Putin for problems in Russia, economic or otherwise. Most people believe whatever the official party line happens to be regardless of what country it is. Look at how many people in the U.S. believed the Bush administration's lies about why we had to invade Iraq? A comfortable lie will beat an unpleasant truth every time.
ReplyDeleteAs for Ukraine, . . . you guys are so screwed. By the time anyone in the West decides that yes, we'll actually live up to our promises, Putin will have succeeded in redrawing the border. He'll have peeled off the 6 or 7 oblasts he wants for that land bridge to Crimea, and that will be that. Here in the U.S., Obama isn't going to do anything except talk, and by the time there's a change in administrations, it'll be too late to affect events in Ukraine. Same is true in Europe. From what I've seen, Merkel's primary motive is to try to slow things down a little without any of the western European countries actually doing anything. Lots of talk and no real substance.
You are exactly right on both counts. If people feel their country is under attack by an outside force they will rally round the flag. Always. No country was ever bombed into submission.
DeleteUkraine is screwed. France and Germany do not want another competitor in the EU and if they can go back to doing profitable business with Russia would likely give him the Yalta 1945 boundaries he wants so much, regardless of what Eastern and Central Europe think about it.
I am in regular communication with two individuals regarding genealogy research; one lives in Russia, the other in Ukraine (not mentioning cities). In recent emails I have been dismayed by the virulent hatred shown towards the USA. They know I am Canadian. They firmly believe the Kremlin's version of the conflict in Ukraine -- it is all caused by American aggression towards Russia. I asked why is it that I only see Russian tanks and Russian soldiers bombing Ukrainian villages. Where are the American tanks and soldiers? The response -- The USA are masters at getting others to fight their wars for them. What the . . . . .
ReplyDeleteUnless you have low blood pressure, they sound like people to avoid. Same with reading on-line comments on articles in the internet. Putin is creating a country full of ignorant hateful people. The one in five or one in six people who do not approve of Putin are in a very dangerous situation. With modern technology, I am sure the FSB know who they are, at least the ones who will be dealt with first. Did you see the article where Putin closed down the Museum to Soviet Political Repression at Perm 36?
DeleteConsidering how easy it is for people to be identified online and through facial recognition at public assemblies, it's amazing anybody has the courage to express an opposing view. There are some very brave people over there.
ReplyDeleteExactly. They are very brave to even turn up for a march, facing possible arrest, harassment, prison, murder...
DeleteAs individuals most people are good;; but let them organize and out comes the worst
ReplyDeletethe Ol'Buzzard
Most people are good but the 5% who are not become the problem and good people get dragged in.
Delete