Today, March 20, 2021 is the Vernal Equinox. The call of the spring equinox is ancient and primal. For millennia, humankind has tracked the sun and the seasons and celebrated the promise of renewal and rebirth by joining together outdoors. A good day to discuss St. Patrick, the main patron saint of the Irish, who allegedly died on March 17th, sometime in the fifth century.
St. Patrick's Day was observed as a rather serious and religious day in Ireland and the celebrations as we know them today really took off in America, where the Irish, tired of being discriminated against and realizing they had strength in numbers turned it into a glorious day for the "wearin' o' the green", and the gettin' of the inebriated. That tradition was more fun and therefore spread around the world
Having a certain amount of Irish extraction in my forbearers, I went along with the tradition wishing people Happy St Patrick's Day and rather than consume green beer, collected Irish jokes, some of which can be printed on a public page.
I know the usual stuff about St Patrick, how he was born to wealthy Christian Roman parents in Wales, was kidnapped and spent several miserable years in Ireland, escaped, went to France and became a priest then returned to Ireland bringing them Christianity. He incorporated the sun which the Irish worshipped into the cross, creating the Celtic Cross, taught the Holy Trinity using the Shamrock, and of course, drove the snakes out of Ireland.
Except this year, I got a bit of a rude awakening from my FB and Blogger friend in Texas, Jackiesue, aka Yellow Dog Granny. Jackiesue is an avowed Pagan who worships The Goddess. I never asked which one as there are several to choose from but personally I'd pick Freya, the Norse goddess of cats, fertility, war, love, sex, beauty, magic and in some ways death. That description fits Jackiesue to a T.
Anyway, Jackiesue informed me that St Patrick was a murderous SOB who Christianized Ireland by killing off the Druids who revered snakes as part of the circle of life, and any other pagans who refused to convert. I ran into this on a number of other people's St Patrick's Day Posts and began to wonder what rock I had been under all these years. The best descriptor was "Happy “another Christian
celebrated for mass slaughter of people with other beliefs” day! Let’s get
drunk!
Now no Irish ever let the truth stand in the way of a good story, so when I started digging to find out who St Patrick really was, I was not surprised to learn the vast majority of information on His Greenness was myth. All we really know according to Britannica is from two short works he wrote: the Confessio,
a spiritual autobiography, and his Letter to Coroticus, a denunciation of mistreatment of Irish Christians.
Everything else is conjecture and legend as there were no written records. The Irish to that time depended on oral history. Hagiographies of St Patrick began to be written in the seventh century by which time he was already venerated as a saint.
First off, St Patrick was not the first Christian missionary in Ireland, and while he did convert many, paganism was never really eliminated but thrived until the fourteenth century and still exists today.
Second, there never were snakes in Ireland when it was inhabited by humans. The ice killed them all. So what did St Patrick do to the 'snakes' i.e. the Druids and other pagans? Today, Christians assert that St. Patrick only banished a
sacrificial Druid religion, an expulsion symbolically represented by the
banishment of snakes. Pagans, on the other hand, claim that St. Patrick forced
Christian conversion with the threat of violence, and actually killed many
Druid priests who refused to convert.
One side glorifies St. Patrick as a
peaceful man doing the Lord’s peaceful work while demonizing a corrupt Druid
culture by accusing it of practicing child sacrifice, and the other side
glorifies Druid culture as living in innocent harmony with nature while
demonizing St. Patrick by accusing him of being a violent missionary. (Where have we heard this stuff before?)
Here is one perspective from the Pagan side and note she does not mention murder of pagans. My surname is Mulkieran. That surname is associated with the
parish of Clonkennkerrill near the small modern village of Gurteen, in Galway.
It was first recorded in the early 11th Century, and other early recordings
include Maelisa O’Mulkieran who died in 1197. My mother was a passionate genealogist,
who traced our family farther back than that. So you might say that my Irish
bonafides have been well established.
I mention this for no other reason than to be able to point
out that my perception of Saint Patrick when I was growing up was vastly
different from the popular secular view. My mother was a seventh generation
hereditary witch, from a long line of women who rejected the Christian
tradition of assuming the names of their husbands and kept her family name.
There’s not a hyphen among the seven women who preceded me, and each one of
them passed down the Pagan traditions which I hold dear today. Among these was
a distaste for Saint Patrick (to say the least – my grandmother would spit at
the mention of his name), who my family saw as a Christian invader, a
missionary who was instrumental in the subjugation of the Irish isle to the
Christian church (and who, worst of all, wasn’t even Irish).
It wasn’t arbitrary that the day honoring Saint
Patrick was placed on the 17th of March. The festival was designed to coincide,
and, it was hoped, to replace the Pagan holiday known as Ostara; the second
spring festival which occurs each year, which celebrates the rebirth of nature,
the balance of the universe when the day and night are equal in length, and
which takes place at the Spring Equinox. In other words,
Saint Patrick’s Day is yet another Christian replacement for a much older,
ancient Pagan holiday; although generally speaking Ostara was most prominently
replaced by the Christian celebration of Easter (the eggs and the bunny come
from Ostara traditions, and the name “Easter” comes from the Pagan goddess
Eostre).The best source I found to refute the idea of a murderous St Patrick is Saint Patrick, Druids, Snakes, and Popular Myths. It looks at several perspectives and quotes backup references. I'm only going to copy a bit of it here but please read the whole thing.
For years now, several individuals have worked to debunk this idea as well. It seems the “snakes = Druids” metaphor is a relatively recent invention, as was the idea that Patrick “drove them out.” P. Sufenas Virius Lupus, a Celtic Reconstructionist Pagan (and scholar) who has extensively studied Irish myth and folklore, had this to say on the subject.
“Unfortunately, this isn’t true, and the hagiographies of St. Patrick did not include this particular “miracle” until quite late, relatively speaking (his earliest hagiographies are from the 7th century, whereas this incident doesn’t turn up in any of them until the 11th century). St. Patrick’s reputation as the one who Christianized Ireland is seriously over-rated and overstated, as there were others that came before him (and after him), and the process seemed to be well on its way at least a century before the “traditional” date given as his arrival, 432 CE, because Irish colonists (yes, you read that right!) in southern Wales, Cornwall, and elsewhere in Roman and sub-Roman Britain had already come into contact with Christians and carried the religion back with them when visiting home.”
His assertions are backed up by historian Ronald Hutton in his book “Blood & Mistletoe: The History of The Druids in Britain.”
“[Saint Patrick’s] letters do, however, strongly suggest that the importance of Druids in countering his missionary work was inflated in later centuries under the influence of biblical parallels, and that Patrick’s visit to Tara was given a pivotal importance that it never possessed – if it ever occurred at all – to suit later political preoccupations. […] The only appearances of Druids in documents attributed to Patrick himself occur in some that are generally thought to have been composed after his death.”
Being neither Green nor Orange but some other form of Irish Protestant heathen I will continue to appreciate Irish jokes and wish people Happy St Patrick's Day (but not you, Jackiesue nor anyone else who objects). And I will not celebrate anything orange!
Links to articles I sourced:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Patrick
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Saint-Patrick
https://www.history.com/topics/st-patricks-day/who-was-saint-patrick
https://www.irishcentral.com/roots/history/saint-patrick-saintly-criminal
https://blog.oup.com/2014/09/real-story-saint-patrick/
https://www.themarysue.com/the-truth-about-saint-patrick-snakes-pagans-and-more/
https://sojo.net/articles/saint-patrick-druids-and-snakes-truth-middle
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/saint-patrick-and-the-sna_b_503252
https://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/2011/nov/15/st-patrick-banish-snakes-ireland