Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

The Battle of Berezina

Two hundred years ago, from November 25th through to 29th, the final battle of Napoleon's 1812 Russian Campaign occurred at the crossing of the Berezina River.

The French army was in full retreat from Moscow, forced to retrace the same route as they had traveled in the summer. With no foraging possible for man or beast, horses and humans were dying as they marched. The cavalry was virtually afoot and hundreds of supply wagons were abandoned.  (It was not the bitter Russian winter that did them in, it was starvation.  Severe winter never came to Russia until after the French were in Poland).

The Berezina River was the last major crossing before the safety of the  Polish border.  Roughly 40,000 French soldiers and 40,000 civilian followers or non-combatants arrived at the river November 25th.  They planned on crossing on the ice and Napoleon had ordered all bridge construction materials destroyed a few days previously.  However, unseasonable warmth meant the river was thawed and impassable. The only bridge at Borisov had been blown by the Russians.

The Russian army had 34,000 men under Chichagov on the west bank of the Berezina while Wittgenstein was approaching from the north with 30,000.  Kutuzov was following about 40 km behind with another 54,000 soldiers.  The plan was to trap and destroy the French army and capture Napoleon.

From Wikipedia 
Napoleon sent Odinot south on the 25th with enough soldiers to draw Chichagov's force , believing the French intended to escape to the south.  It worked.  In the meantime, as not all bridge materials had been destroyed, the engineers set to work building two 100 meter bridges across the icy water at a ford near Studenka, further north.  By the 26th, the bridges were complete and enough French forces and cannon across to hold the bridgehead when Chichagov realized he had been had.

Victor was left behind to fight rear guard against Wittgenstein's army and on the night of the 29th, the last survivors made their way across the bridges.  Those non-combatants who had not managed to cross were left behind to the tender mercies of the Cossacks. Estimates of French and Russian losses vary widely but French losses ranged from 15,000 to 25,000 combatants and 10,000 to 20,000 civilian non-combatants.

From Wikipedia
Napoleon had been campaigning on two fronts in 1812 and loosing both (Wellington's army and Spanish guerrillas were chasing the Grande Armee all over Spain).  Plots were hatching to dump Napoleon who had to leave the remnants of his army at Berezina and hurry home to save his throne.

The Battle of Berezina was a strategic success for Napoleon as he escaped and his troops were not completely annihilated, leaving sufficient to rebuild his army the following year. The Russians failed to stop him because they really were not that committed to doing so, while the French were fighting for their lives.

Kutuzov, who did not arrive in time, never had any intent whatsoever to do so.  If he had had his way, not a single Russian soldier would have lost his life fighting Napoleon. Kutuzov realized that Napoleon was beaten as soon as he crossed into Russia, that distance and weather would do the army's work for them.  His objective was simply to clear the last French soldier out of Russia and they were going.

Russia's failure to stop Napoleon at Berezina resulted in two more years of war plus the "100 days" in 1815 before Napoleon was finally finished. 

Thursday, November 25, 2010

Happy Thanksgiving, America

For those of you interested in such things, I recommend the book Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community, and War by Nathaniel Philbrick.  It is a very readable history of the Pilgrims in New England.

 In the meantime, enjoy your family and the turkey.

Sunday, September 5, 2010

Ancient and Historical Khakasia

The Asian grasslands, which includes much of Kazakhstan, Mongolia and central Siberia were settled long ago and have a very rich archaeological history.  Khakasia is no exception. I always maintain the reason that the Asian steppes were the progenitors of so many modern peoples is that there was nothing to do there but fight and flirt and in winter it was too cold to fight.

When Tanya and I were there in 2006, we did a one day tour of sites with the head of the Archaeology Department from the University, a native Khakasian.   Igor Tashtandinov had been born in Tanya's village of Kalyagino and his mother was best friends with Tanya's mother, though he and Tanya had never met.

Igor and Tanya 2006
Archaeological sites go back 10,000 years at least.  The most  recent peoples were the Kyrgyz who were over run by the Mongolians some 800 years ago and most drifted to modern Kyrgyzstan.  Today's Khkasians are decendants of the Kyrgiz who stayed behind.

10,000 year old rock drawings
More 10,000 year old drawings
Sketches of rock drawings in Abakan Museum

3,000 years old.  Food offerings were poked into the hole in the rock.
Over 200,000 kurgans dot the plains and hills of Khakasia
A large mound kurgan
Kurgan cross section, Abakan museum
Early people of the Steppes
Female fertility stele
Male strength stele
Archaeological dig of a palace, possibly of a Chinese general from the Han dynasty era who defected to the Xiongnu
Model of the 2000 year old palace, Abakan museum
I'll post some landscape pictures next time.

Sunday, May 9, 2010

An Historical Event

Foreign troops marched in Red Square today as part of the Russian V.E. Day celebrations.  Troops from Allied nations - USA, Great Britain, France and Poland participated in the huge parade involving some 11,000 troops and a 1000 person band. 

The last time there were foreign troops (not counting troops from various countries of the Russian/Soviet Empire, of course) on Red Square may well have been 1812 during Napoleon's brief stopover. 

Angela Merkel was in the crowd of dignitaries. Prince Charles was not, though he offered.

It was the first time since the dissolution of the USSR that military hardware was on parade.  I was interested in the T-34's and the old WWII uniforms more than the modern stuff.  I have no way of knowing if the modern weaponry displayed is  technically advanced or if it would be effective against an enemy armed with similar stuff.  It is great stuff for the last war (they clobbered mighty Georgia) but not likely too useful for the next wars if Afghanistan, Chechnya, Sudan and Iraq are any indication. 

There were many old men and women in uniform, loaded with medals, tears in their eyes, as they remembered The Great Patriotic War.  The hardships, the suffering, the loved ones lost.  And they looked some proud as the soldiers marched and the hardware rolled past.

The USSR was never defeated.  It collapsed from within of its own weight.  Destroyed by Gorbachev and Yeltsin if you ask the person on the street.  This leaves a great deal of room for "stabbed in the back" theories and for machinations around extreme nationalism. Sound familiar?  Stay tuned.

Saturday, May 8, 2010

V.E. Day

May 9th is V.E. Day.  Much celebrated in Russia and Ukraine.  The rest of eastern Europe not so much as they traded Hitler's Nazi's for 45 years of occupation by Stalin's Communists and those of his successors.

Russia makes much of its victory over Hitler as in the last 100 years, it was about the only thing they got right.  If you don't count 20 million dead.  Many of them to Stalin's incompetence as a military commander and many of them to Stalin's forced deportation of millions of people to east of the Urals, where a third to half died (on the way or after arrival).  We are still inundated with WWII movies on TV.  New ones and old ones.

So today the veterans are honoured and the dead remembered in parades and at memorials across the countries.  These working girls from a cartoon in the local paper are doing their part.  The sign reads: Holiday Special: Veterans of Great Patriotic War 30% discount.  The hopeful young man is inquiring if they have student rates.